top of page

Historiscizing

Inflinite Scroll

Digital Behaviours

Exploring

User Engagement in

Persuasive Technologies
 

Generative Research

Participatory focus groups

Ethnography

Online Research

Speculative design

My role

Research Plan and Execution

Participatory Activities

Speculative Writing and Animation 

Outcome

A Timeline of

Personalized Recommendations 

A Speculative design fiction 

based on research insights 

Overview

This exploratory project investigates the evolving content consumption patterns users have developed with social media and streaming platforms.

The study focuses on 2 specific UI patterns - Infinite scroll and personalized recommendations.

Intentions

Affordances

Interfaces

When does persuasiveness in tech become deceptiveness?
How do the affordances of the form of content influence the way we consume it?
How do the designed interfaces shape behaviors?

Research Questions

Research Design

Digital behaviours are not accidental but by design. Modern day applications use reward systems, internal motivators and psychological triggers to keep people engaged for as long as possible.


This behaviour structuring mechanism is due to the revenue models of tech companies. Keeping people enagaged allows the monitoring of people’s behaviours wants, needs, likes and dislikes.

​

What makes tech "persuasive" ?  

Persuasive Technologies use multiple patterns to keep people hooked onto their screens. One such pattern is Infinite scroll.

Tracing Infinite scroll to its origins, we find its implemention on a blog called 'Humanized' from Aza Raskin who is famously known as the inventor of infinite scroll. 

​

The idea he used to popularize it in the following years was -

It will reduce interaction (by reducing clicks) and solve the drop-off rates from pagination

​

Instagram was an early adopter of Infinite Scroll in 2010, Facebook and twitter in 2011, followed by Pinterest Tumblr and Reddit. The growing popularity of touchscreen phones and apps led to widespread use of of infinite scroll.

​

SCROLL.  SCROLL. SCROLLSCROLL SCROOOOOOLLLLL. SCROLL. SCROLL.  SCROLL. SCROLLSCROLL SCROOOLLLLLLLL. SCRO

SCROLL.  SCROLL. SCROLLSCROLL SCROOOOOOLLLLL. SCROLL. SCROLL.  SCROLL. SCROLLSCROLL SCROOOLLLLLLLL. SCRO

Historiscizing

Personalized Recommendation

Tracing the developments in recommendation systems through time to understand the current scenario

​

Insights 

Privacy in content consumption - People don't always want their friends and family to know what they're watching 

Perceived Rating - People's perceptions of rating scales are varied and may give an arbitrary idea of likes/dislikes

Why implicit data - When asked explicitly, people may indicate content interests they aspire to have and not really have

Interoperability of features - A pattern or feature that  successfully drives engagement is likely to be replicated by other apps  

User familiarity - UI elements or patterns become symbolic of the corresponding action and different apps or platforms leverage this familiarity for improved user experience 

Group discussions to understand different people's perspectives through a collection of their digital experience. The purpose behind this is to gather user stories that form insights 

Participatory Sensemaking

Session 3

Structuring the Participation

Session 2

Session 1

Showcasing the narrative​

Discussing the outcome and its effect

​

​

Project introduction

​

Inquiring about people's digital experience and anecdotes from their interaction with the two UI patterns  

​

Provoking and probing questions using artefacts

​

Sharing my Ideation with the participants

​

Discussing insights from other methods in relation the previous conversations​

Session mode - remote 

Tools used - google meet for discussion, figjam for easy collaboration 

​

​

​

chris-montgomery-smgTvepind4-unsplash.jpg

To encourage participants' contribution I used 2 modes 

whiteboarding spaces on figjam for each group to brainstorm

a WhatsApp group to share screenshots and instances they would like to share

​

​

​

Digital Ethnography is conducted through the digital medium by observing peoples' engagement in that digital space. 

For this context, I chose to observe app features related to recommendations and interact with people on Reddit to note their experiences. 

​

​

Digital Ethnography

IMG_0376.JPG
IMG_0375.jpg
IMG_0378.jpg
IMG_0374.JPG
IMG_0377.jpg

Negative experiences - Lack of choice in filtering recommendations

People's solutions to endless scrolling - self restriction, alternative applications  

Clickbait and sensationalized content used to increase views 

IMG_6516.PNG

Content success metrics driving sensationalization, triggering content 

IMG_5805 (1).jpg
IMG_5806 (1).jpg

Features indicating explicit mention of  user's choice

IMG_5794 (1).PNG
IMG_5794 (1).PNG
IMG_5879.PNG
IMG_5880.PNG
IMG_5879.PNG

Narrative Building

Identifying Weak Signals

For speculating a future scenario for the design fiction, there needs to be a collection of signals that show where we are headed in terms of tech developments. 

​

​

Screenshot 2024-05-09 150259.jpg
Screenshot 2024-05-09 145628.jpg
Screenshot 2024-05-09 151150.png

“Besieged by automated recommendations, we are left to
guess exactly how they are influencing us, feeling in some
moments misperceived or misled and in other moments
clocked with eerie precision. At times, the computer
sometimes seems more in control of our choices than we are.
”
Article by Chayka, K.(2022, July 25) The Age of Algorithmic Anxiety

​

​

Habit Formation - Algorithmically driven engagement 

Screenshot 2024-05-09 152016.jpg
Screenshot 2024-05-09 152549.jpg
Screenshot 2024-05-09 153645.jpg

Potential changes in devices/ content mediums 

​

​

videoframe_787161.jpg

"Blink In Lio"

Content surveillance and moderation  

Apple-WWDC23-Vision-Pro-rotation-230605.jpg.large_2x.jpg
Screenshot 2024-05-19 134354.jpg
Screenshot 2024-05-09 155218.jpg

Possible solutions​

​

Screenshot 2024-05-09 155026.jpg

Premise of the narrative

In a world where
A big tech corporation ‘Nova’ controls the world through content consumption patterns,
People
have lost control over their attention and sense of individual identity.
But
An ex-techworker finds a way to rebel with a new invention

The narrative introduces a world sometime in the future where people use Nova, a device developed by a company of the same name. This device fuses with people’s senses once mounted at the back of the ear and floats interfaces in from of your eyes. The interface is personalized, visible only to the person using it and not to those around. It can see what you see and hear what you hear.


Since it can observe closely all your interactions, it is an accurate recommendation machine which people have grown to rely on. People believe Nova to be future predicting and are hooked to its delight. Because of its addictive nature people have a hard time living in reality which makes it necessary to have spaces that enforce some digital free time for a time based charge. These are called digital gardens.


The protagonist is Rishi Roy, a former Nova employee who walks us through the working of Nova. Once he learns that the recommendation system for Nova uses surveillance, he realizes that these devices take away their decision making capacity and autonomy over attention. He then tries to develop a better algorithm that gives more control to the user, along with his trusted senior colleague. However, his immediate firing as he brings up an ethical lens leaves him in shock.

IMG_0460.PNG
Dream 3..png
Siddhesh Gupte_WIP1.PNG
Screenshot 2024-07-26 025914.jpg

The final output was an animation film with the research insights embedded into the visual narrative.  

Questionnaire

How do you start your day?

When is the first contact with any kind of tech?

Occupation - While you work how often do you use the phone?

What kind of content do you watch? Which platforms, Why?

How were you introduced to this platform?

​

Exploratory

Explanatory

Descriptive

Predictive

Can you describe which apps you use at which instances?

Do you watch more often than you would like to? Why do you think so?

Do you watch more on the phone, TV or Laptop? Why?

How were you watching content when you first started?

Can you open (the discussed platform) and point out (how you use/ why you keep using/ why you cant stop using) this platform based on the feature?

(I will inquire more based on the response)

Can you mention some particular scenarios when you find yourself scrolling more than you would like?

What analogies can you give for this?

for example - scrolling is like getting on a train that never stops

What makes you say that?

​

How do you think content will be viewed in the future, in

10-15 years?

How do you see the form of tech evolving?

Imagine yourself in that time using that technology, completing a task that you described earlier.  Can you describe how that scenario

​

​

To find

possibly unknown phenomenons

To explore

particular phenomenons

To understand process behind certain outcomes 

To nudge more towards reflection of present

Main Findings

  • Phone checking is habitual, first thing after waking up as well as throughout the day.

  • For the majority, clearing notifications at every chance is not just a mandatory chore but gets in the way of other activities.  

  • Participants are aware of the co-relation between the platform and amount time they might end up spending

  • They mention Youtube (with mid sized content) to be the most unknowingly time consuming  

  • When describing persuasiveness, the main features mentioned are convenience and lack of cognitive break.  

  • They also mention their current life situations and their relation to their phone usage. Like participants using LinkedIn for most of the day slip into Instagram and other apps unknowingly due to easy switchability 

​

  • Participants say that they see having little to no control over their content viewing in the future. 

  • They describe different ways in which devices might become more integrated to humans for easier access

Product Insights and Actionable suggestions 

Just as an "almost full" battery slows down the charging to prevent damage, a similar principle of relative functioning can be implemented where the app can slow down or pause to provide a cognitive break to the user by creating  a buffer zone.

User autonomy - To provide more control over usage, engagement tracking, reminders, alerts for overusage can be implemented in the apps. 

Redefining Success - New metrics can be introduced that derive the content success measure from the combined value provided by quality and quantity of engagement. This will reduce shortcut methods to acquire engagement like triggering or

misleading thumbnails. 

Frame 2.jpg
Frame 3.jpg
Frame 4.jpg

Positive reactions +high engagement 

Negative reactions
+ High engagement

Contextual Factors - People's engagement changes with changing life situations. There can be adaptive modes that shift the purpose of app usage according to the user's wishes. For example, focus mode - for viewing content recommendations from a selected category and length

MacBook Pro 14_ - 1.jpg

User forum - A space for users to communicate their frustrations with newly released/ existing features as well as put out requests based on arising requirements or pain points

bottom of page